Peanut Butter Caramel Cookie
Peanut Butter Caramel Cookie
Handmade in Chico since 2010 · Ships within 2–3 business days · 7-day happiness guarantee · Free gift message at checkout
Store rating
Indulge in our signature Peanut Butter Caramel Cookie, crafted with a closely guarded recipe that balances rich peanut butter with buttery caramel notes. Each cookie features a center of our handmade vanilla caramel, melted to perfection for a luxurious texture contrast. The result is a sophisticated treat that delivers depth of flavor in every bite—ideal for those who appreciate artisanal confections made with care and quality ingredients.
Share
What customers say about Terri Sue's
Shipping, Freshness & Our Guarantee
Shipping & Freshness
Made fresh to order in our Chico, California kitchen and carefully packed to arrive fresh and beautiful. Free standard shipping on orders of $79 or more (per shipping address); otherwise from $6.95 depending on order size and destination. Need it faster? Contact us before ordering and we'll quote expedited. Best enjoyed within 2–3 weeks of arrival. Sending a gift? Add a free gift message at checkout and we'll ship straight to your recipient — beautifully packed and ready to give.
Our Guarantee
If anything arrives less than perfect, contact us within 7 days and we'll make it right — with a replacement or a full refund. No hassle, no questions asked.